Part of the America at a Crossroads documentary series aired on PBS earlier this year, Operation Homecoming is a unique approach at representing the war. Taking writings from soldiers deployed in Iraq, the producers of Operation Homecoming created a series of visual vignettes, attempting to create a wide variety of visual approaches to the writings and the subject matter. The visual styles range from animation, cinema verite, re-enactments, and CGI graphics.
This is quite an amazing story and the animation is so unique! I felt like I was in the middle of the action. It leaves me with a vivid sense of what the soldiers might be experiencing.
Posted Jul 27, 2007
09:22 AM
by com
Los Angeles, CA
Men in Black /is/ very creative, although I think some of the others are a little more 'critical' in form and interesting, in particular the piece with the added words I find thought-provoking...
How does the addition of words in this "documentary" reflect the manipulation of "media" representations of the war? etc...
The entire Operation Homecoming project is pretty interesting...
Posted Aug 27, 2007
11:31 AM
by Casual Hero
Los Angeles, CA
I can understand the need for slight artistic deviation on some of these stories by a filmmaker, but these instances of "word additions" are dishonest and they undermine the real spirit of their respective stories.
In "Medevac Missions" especially, one such addition is visibly designed to misrepresent US combat tactics as being highly criminal in nature. By fabricating conversations about the blatant killing of innocent Iraqi children by US Troops, the filmmaker attempts to tack on a unsubstantiated dimension of horror to an already reprehensible set of circumstances that have resulted from this war. I would think that the broken and mangled bodies of our wounded would be enough to get the point across; making up war crimes is just a CHEAP SHOT.
Posted Feb 18, 2008
08:47 AM
by travlnurs
CA
appreciate the feelings of the aeromedical evacuation crewmembers. Been there, done that. It's true, you do what you do to get them through the airlift. You move them from here to there and mostly never know where they go or how they do. But we keep on doing our part -- that's why we signed up, and I still feel very grateful that I can do this job.
Posted Feb 18, 2008
08:47 AM
by Kmuzu
A very acurate story of why war is hell. May your shoe box not stay empty.
Posted Feb 18, 2008
08:48 AM
by Adam Hyman
Los Angeles, CA
Greetings. I'm co-producer of the film and will reply occasionally to feedback. I just waned to respond to Casual Hero's note at this time. I'm unclear about the "word addition" that you refer to in "Medevac Missions." There is no such addition in that story, and the writing is by a medevac nurse from his own experiences, not fictionalized. There is no fabricated conversation. Only the story "What Every Soldier Should Know" has visual word additions, which serve a different purpose in that piece. Thank you for writing in.